By Don Kenton Henry
His life had always been about structure. It is what made Bonham Cartwright so successful in academics, graduating at the top of his class in the undergraduate Criminal Justice program at Texas A&M, then with honors from Boston University with a Masters in Biomedical Forensic Science. And structure was what had made Bonham Austin’s most respected and consulted homicide detective after an illustrious ten year career with the Rangers. His disciplined and ordered life required structure in order for him to function. So much so, it had cost him two childless marriages by the age of forty-five. Neither Sarah or Joan could adhere to the rigorous requirement for order Bonham demanded in his life. And both wives had wanted children. But neither had heeded his honest pre-nuptial disclosure that children were the kind of chaos with which his mind and regimen could not be distracted and each left in sight of two years for what Bonham described as, “more fertile pastures”. From the way his black Lucchese boots had to be shined to a point he could see the reflection of his Stetson in them, to the flat-top hair cut and straight razor shave, all three of which he got to start the week each Monday at a barber shop on South Congress within blocks of the Capitol―to the way he took off that hat, his service revolver, cuffs and badge and carefully arranged them on the nightstand next to his bed each evening. Everything about his life and bearing reflected perfection, precision and balance. Perfect order. And that is why the slightest disorder, unnoticed by lesser detectives, jumped out at Bonham Cartwright like a runaway freight train in a rose garden or an elephant in ballet slippers. “Have you always been such an obsessive freak, Bonnie?” Joan (his second wife) had said as she exited their porch to take leave of their home and marriage less than three years earlier.
He answered from the dining room table over which he stood arranging the place setting (now for one) for his next meal, still precisely four hours away, “Could you please come back and shut the door behind you?”
And that is why the unsolved, horrendous and bizarre case of the Patterson grave, “Baby, Jane Doe”, haunted him so. Ten years with the Texas Ranger’s investigative unit and ten more with the City of Austin and it was the only blemish on an otherwise stellar career. The only unsolved case out of hundreds he had been assigned.
It all began in 2009 when a perfectly attired―down to the pink bow on the top right of her delicate little head and the swaddling (of the same color) she was wrapped in―baby girl, was found at the bottom of an open and empty Patterson family grave. It was in the historic Oakwood Cemetery, originally City Cemetery, Austin’s oldest. Dating from the mid-1850’s, many of Austin’s founders and earliest settlers, along with paupers, are buried there. All lie together, atop a hill, in what is now the center of the city. Bonham’s own ancestors and family, including his father, an Austin policeman himself, killed in the line of duty, are buried there. It was a grave awaiting the intended resident―intended to occupy it just moments later. The funeral party, which surrounded the grave to pay their last respects to their loved one, let out a collective gasp as a graveside attendant, peering down, cried out in shock as the coffin was being maneuvered into position. With that, the entire funeral party edged forward and stared at this precious little baby, six feet down. Apparently perfect in every way, she appeared to be sleeping. Perfectly attired. Perfectly positioned. Perfectly beautiful. Perfectly dead. An autopsy revealed she had been born alive just a day or two before. Then suffocated. The coroner’s reported indicated the date of death as October 18th.
Of course, detective Bonham Cartwright was the first to be assigned the macabre case. His background in biomedical forensic science combined with extensive street experience made that a given. Forensics revealed no clues as to the baby’s identity and there was no DNA match in any data base which might have given clues as to her parents. Fiber analysis told nothing of her last location prior to the grave. No births matching her description were reported by hospitals and no reports of a missing or deceased child were made. As to that last fact, the prevailing theory was that the baby’s birth, and possibly even its mother’s pregnancy, had been kept secret so that no one other than the parents, or mother herself, knew of its existence and therefore could not report it missing or dead. Five years later, the case appeared to be cold. At a dead end. But murder cases are never closed. Especially when Bonham Cartwright is on the case ― and especially when a dead baby, which had every reason to be living today, was callously placed in a grave meant for another. Especially when the otherwise perfect order of Bonham’s structured life was disrupted at three in the morning, almost every morning, with the image of that pink bundle in a six foot hole. Or each time he drove past Oakwood or stopped to visit the family plot. And now, Baby Jane Doe was there also. Awaiting justice for a life she had so briefly. Awaiting her own name to be placed above her own grave. She was in a coffin Bonham had chosen to pay for with his own money and laid to rest in the Cartwright family plot following a service only he attended. Through a telephoto lens, a photographer from the Austin American Statesman caught a picture of him kneeling graveside in the shade of one of the cemetery’s numerous live oaks. The paper and community had not let go of this sordid story since. And of this there is no doubt: This case was a heavy albatross about detective Bonham Cartwright’s neck and the stench of it filled him to the point it oozed from his pores and obscured that of the rank and putrid cesspool of Austin’s underbelly into which he waded each day as he slid his badge in his pocket and went out the door.
Amid the numerous gang related and assorted murders in the Texas State Capitol; amid images of hundreds of bloodied faces, crushed skulls and hemorrhaged torsos, Baby Jane Doe’s face and her little pink bow kept coming into view like one on the slide show of an electronic picture frame. And so came the occasional mysterious clue. The first two came a week apart immediately following the funeral and were cryptic enough Bonham wasn’t fully certain they were related to Baby Jane Doe. Of the third clue, arriving three weeks after her funeral, there was no doubt. All three were in the form of messages and all were sent on plain white computer paper in non-descript white envelopes, the kind which can be purchased at any convenience store or Wal-Mart. The letters of the actual message were mostly glossy and cut and pasted from what were obviously magazines and none so distinct as to determine which. All were addressed to him at the Department on E. 8th Street with a label printed by one of what could have been at least a million Dymo printers and all were postmarked at the Austin post office on Guadalupe just a few blocks away. A tedious search and follow-up of all owners of that printer within a hundred mile radius, owners that had registered for warranty purposes, produced no leads. Neither the postage stamps, the envelopes or their contents contained any evidence of DNA or finger prints.
The third message read: “Rock a bye baby, ‘neath the tree top. You’ve found a home in a plot with a cop.”
“What kind of sick pervert adulterates a nursery rhyme to glamorize a baby’s murder?” Bonham thought, as he sent his sack lunch flying with a sweep of his hand. It sailed from the top of his desk, hit and slid down the wall. Quickly, he rose to retrieve it and placed it neatly back on the upper right corner of his desk, the order of his office briefly disrupted by one impulsive and uncharacteristic display of emotion.
The next message did not arrive until six months thereafter. It came the same way in the same format and read: “Patty Cake, Patty Cake, Detective Man . . . Solve my murder as fast you can!”
“The killer is taunting me,” Bonham thought. “No, she or he―or whoever it is―is trying to torture me!”
He had, for the time, exhausted every lead and discounted every theory ventured as to the identity of the perpetrator. Then he remembered the words of, Sheriff Joe Petri, of Paradise in West Texas, Comanche County. Sheriff Joe was his mentor when Bonham was with the Rangers and his mentor still and he always said:
“You don’t need to see every flea on a dog to know he’s got ’em. You just gotta see him scratchin’. When you stand so close to a case all you see are a thousand possibilities, keep walking back until you see the big picture. The answers in there somewhere. Just keep walking back until you find it. You’ve just been tripping over details.” And so, from above, Bonham pictured Baby Jane Doe, all wrapped in pink, at the bottom of that black grave. And he kept walking back, like up a staircase, rising higher above it until he saw first his own plot in the cemetery. And he rose higher still until he saw East Austin and then all of Austin with the Capitol plunked right there in the center of it. And still he saw no killer.
Soon thereafter, he decided to contact a pre-eminent forensic psychiatrist from Boston he had interviewed for his master’s thesis and with whom, through the years, he consulted when the department’s own shrinks failed to develop a criminal profile which led him to the killer.
“This one’s got me, Dr. Johansson. It’s consuming me and I can’t, for the life of me, wrap my mind around or envision what kind of miscreant does something like this, ” said Detective Cartwright into the receiver of his office phone. Given the details I’ve provided, what is your initial reaction? In what direction do I go from here?”
“Well, Bonham, you certainly have yourself one for the textbooks and possibly the cinema. I would love to get the person who did this on my couch. But I want you to consider this: My first reaction is that this killer is the mother or killed the mother in addition to the child. If the mother is alive and is not the killer, she knows who the killer is. Let us assume she is alive, as it is fairly safe to do since you tell me there were no reported murders or deaths of females recently with child. And since she has not reported the killer, she either is the killer or is intimidated by the killer. But, regardless, she probably wanted the baby dead. Now if she, or they, only wanted the baby dead, they would have simply buried it in a remote area. Or, if they suffered a total lack of empathy―as we have seen all too often―they would simply have put it in a dumpster just as they would a piece of trash.”
“But they didn’t,” answered Bonham.
“No. They didn’t. What did they do?”
“They put her in a hole ― in a grave for someone else about to be buried.”
“And did they just throw her in that hole?”
“No. They placed her in there. . . . Carefully. She had been placed there very carefully.”
“Yes. Very deliberately. Very strategically, as though she were being put on display. The question is for whom. The funeral party? I presume you have explored those leads?”
“Yes. There is no plausible connection between the baby and any in the funeral party,” Bonham answered confidently.
“It was a theatrical presentation and we can assume they knew the audience was about to fill the theater. They were going for maximum effect . . . they were trying to make a statement.”
“Yes, Dr. Johansson, but to whom ― and what was the statement?”
“Answer the second question and you will be a lot closer to knowing the answer to the first. And when you know that, you will soon know the killer.”
“Thank you, doctor,” said Bonham, his voice trailing off as he hung up the phone. The next messages came sporadically thereafter. Each one was more taunting and cruel than the last but offerd no clues as to the sender’s identity. But the two most recent, arrived in the last two weeks, a week apart. It was as though the sender’s patience had run its course. Almost as though they wanted Bonham to solve the mystery. Both messages struck an ominous chord in his psyche and he felt the hair stand on his neck and arms. The first of these read: “Live girls and boys come out to play. But when the moon shines bright as day, I leave my grave and creep into your sleep. Know this little acorn didn’t fall far from the tree.”
“Tree, what tree?” he thought. “She was surrounded by trees, both in the Patterson grave and now. He focused on the question he posed to doctor Johansson, “What statement was the killer trying to make at the Patterson gravesite? Perfectly placed, attired and displayed. Everything in perfect order. Except that a baby in a grave stood out to everyone standing over it like a runaway freight train in a rose garden. And to none more than Detective Bonham Cartwright. Disorder amidst otherwise perfect order. He desperately tried to resist a sense he did not want to acknowledge.
Then, just today, October 17th, the last message arrived. He opened it and, in doing so, noticed his linen gloved hands were more unsteady than usual. He held his breath as he slowly unfolded then read this message: “Happy birthday to me. Happy birthday to me. Happy birthday, dear daddy . . . Happy Birthday to me!” Now his hands shook so hard he let loose of the letter and let it fall to his desk top. He sat absorbing the implication of the message for some time. Then he reached for the phone and hit the direct line to the Travis County Coroner’s office. Baby Jane Doe’s DNA had, of course, been preserved. Detective Bonham Cartwright’s came back with a 99.99% probability of paternity. He received the results in person in the lab of the medical examiner, Dr. Steven Porter. A lab in which he had shared so many hours over the years. Dr. Porter just stared at Bonham in disbelief as he handed him the results.
Joan lived in east Austin, a bad part of town, in an apartment not too far from Oakwood Cemetery. He had heard she had fallen on hard times since the divorce. With warrant in hand and accompanied by another detective and a uniformed patrolman, he knocked on her door. No one answered and he tried it. It was unlocked and he opened it slowly and entered alone. His eyes focused across the unlit, curtain drawn, darkness of the room to where Joan sat in a stuffed chair turned toward him. An array of pill bottles covered the tray beside it. She slowly smiled a small smile. “I’m surprised it took you so long. You never wanted children. I know you’re glad I spared you that. And you’ve always been such an obsessive freak, Bonnie. . . . So why didn’t you shut the door behind you?”
Detective Bonham Cartwright stood almost at attention as the headstone was placed above the grave. It read, “Bonnie Cartwright, Only Child of Bonham Cartwright”. The photographer from the Austin American Statesman stood behind a live oak and focused his telephoto lens on the scene as Bonham took a knee. . . . . Then the photographer paused and lowered the camera without taking the shot. He turned and walked away.